BadfingerNews Feature:

Without You: The Tragic Story Of Badfinger

revised edtion

BadfingerNews brings you its review, and an exclusive interview with author Dan Matovina



BadfingerNews Review:

The second edition of "Without You: The Tragic Story Of Badfinger" is now ready for release. Dan Matovina has gone through the whole book once again, gathered more info, corrected minor errors, added new pictures, and perhaps most important - included a CD of unreleased demos, studio recordings, phone conversations, and interviews.

The result is even more impressive than the first edition. The book is now up-to-date through July of 2000, which means that it features reports on all the latest events, such as the Day After Day: Live court case, VH-1 program, Very Best Of Badfinger, and much more.

While reading you notice new pictures pop up here and there, and in the middle there are eight insert pages of top quality, and yet un-seen, pictures of the band.

But the most important addition has to be the new CD, with many highlights. -- LINK HERE TO VIEW CD TRACKLIST --

I had expected the CD to be interesting, and quite good, but I definitely hadn't expected to see the until-now unreleased Head First track "Hey, Mr. Manager" on it. The source is the rough Apple mix. A great surprise! Though a remixing of the whole album from the original 16-track masters would be preferable for a issue of the album, this remastered rough Apple mix sounds really really good. The vocal performances (both lead and backing) are impressive.

The CD opens with an early Pete Ham demo "Man Without A Heart", which Pete sings with great passion while trying to keep upon the piano; you can hear he's still learning his way around the piano. Other Pete-Ham-only demos are "Knocking Down Our Home", a new "Ringside", and "Take It All". "Man Without A Heart" is followed by a bunch of Iveys demos. Among them are "Clown Of The Party" that features a typical great, melodic Pete Ham verse. What you notice on these Iveys demos is the backing vocals are sometimes too upfront, but these Iveys tunes shows a band with a great potential, and one shouldn't forget that they are not recorded on top quality recording equipment.

But a top Iveys performance is the BBC recording (top sound quality) of "Maybe Tomorrow". Pete recreates much of the original strings arrangement on his Fender Stratocaster, and it comes out with more edge and not quite as bubbly-gummy as the studio version.

Tom Evans has three "solo" performances, a very quiet "Blind Owl", obviously the tune is all new, but you can hear there is something there, even in this early stage of the song. Next comes "I Believe In You" which is a 4-track recording with the Dodgers. I doubt you will ever hear Tommy, more poppy and upbeat than on this one. Nice to hear. And closing the CD "Over You", taken from the CD of the same name.

In the interviews there is a long one done with Pete and Tom in March of 1974 that touches many issues and is extremely informative. And in the more darker experiences there is one phone conversation with Pete from October 1974, and two with Tom, from May and August 1983. Both of them indicate the troubled state of mind they both were in at the time of these conversations. Especially the last Evans conversation. All in all this new book is a must have for all Badfinger fans, not only to get the accurate Badfinger story and great pictures, but this new CD is a fantastic addition to any Badfinger CD/LP collection. Great job by Dan Matovina - once more!


 

Interview with Dan Matovina

July 2000

Dan Matovina talks about the second edition of his Badfinger biography



1. What was your reason for releasing a revised Badfinger book?

1997's first edition's hardcover and softcovers had sold out. I wanted the book to continue to be available in the marketplace, especially as I felt the alleged pending VH-1 TV documentary was going to happen and that would spark a lot of new interest in Badfinger. I felt the book should be a revised edition because it is a biography, so it inherently strives be as accurate and detailed as possible. Within my budget, I dug up more info, corrected anything I discovered to be wrong factually in the previous edition, fixed some typos, added pictures, and put in a CD of material to help augment the story. The story, though, essentially remains the same with new events and happenings added from 1998 to the year 2000, and nearly complete listings of the studio and live dates of The Iveys and Badfinger put in new appendices.





2. Were there any important new discoveries?

Before I published the first book, I worked very long and very hard to be as thorough and as accurate as possible. And thus, in doing a second edition, it turned out there weren't many events of great significance left to uncover. There were some important events previously reported which I later found the time frames to be different. For example, Tom's getting the Porsche happened in 1972, not 1970 as reported in the first edition. I had been given conflicting accounts on that earlier, and many unsure memories abounded about that incident. When I did the first book, I had originally ascertained late 1970 was likely the era, and mostly I based this on Joey's strong assertion in an interview. But Bill Collins diary totally cleared that event as happening in 1972. Otherwise, there were some event's dates which were discovered to be off a few days or a few months here and there, and I corrected those.

 

3. What do you consider to be the most important additions to this revised book?

Certainly the CD. Music is what draws people to this group in the first place, and I've included a lot of unreleased gems and other significant rarities like "Hey, Mr. Manager." Hopefully this CD will spark more interest in releases of more material. The interviews with Pete and Tom are special because they show you a lot of Pete and Tom's outward personalities, which are pretty much as people interviewed for the book described them. The phone conversations are like moments in time that capture emotions and thoughts going through Pete and Tom's head. They give you deeper insights into the overall story which is so tragic on so many levels.

 

4. How did you pick the material for the second edition CD?

Well, I wanted material that would enrich the experience of going through the book. I had put out some key demos already with the earlier hardcover edition, like the original two songs that became "Without You", but there was a lot more left to choose from. What was great was this new book gave the opportunity to let people hear some recordings which otherwise would likely not ever get out through a larger record company- like the interviews, the phone calls, and the rougher sounding demos, such as "Man Without A Heart." I know many people will be greatly appreciative to hear these things.

 

5. "I Believe In Love" on the CD is a very unusual Tommy Evans song. Was he trying to fit in with The Dodgers' style?

Tommy's writing during the Dodgers period is, overall, a little more upbeat and sunny in nature than the darker moody material he often presented during Pete's day. Actually this Dodgers demo is called "I Believe In You." That is what is listed in the book. The CD booklet has a typo in the title. It will be corrected in future printings.

 

6. What significance do you see in the new "live" and "studio" appendices?

Better context of the band's career. Also, fans can use this info and go to libraries and dig up reviews and ads of the time. People who were at these events may regain a clearer memory and perspective by having these time frames and details pinpointed. I think many fans really enjoy reading other people's personal memories and feelings regarding events they were at. So I encourage people greatly to talk about that and also to relay their personal stories related to the recorded music or meeting the band members.

 

7. Why did you include the Apple mix of "Hey, Mr. Manager" and what do you think of it? How do you view the whole Head First situation?

I feel the song is greatly significant to the story for it's lyrics,plus the obvious development of Tommy as a quality commercial-pop writer. Even though Tommy didn't have a lot of "hits" from his writing, I truly feel many of his songs could have been Top Ten or Top Twenty songs if produced better or covered by other artists. Another reason I put this song on this book CD was to show the sound of the rough mixes is actually pretty decent, despite reports otherwise, and that this discovery will further increase people's interest in purchasing an entire CD of the album when it comes out. Yet, I am a strong advocate that the best scenario for "Head First" is truly a new mix of the album being done and released. But that is going to be difficult to pull off for the near future, based on my recent discussions with Rhino Records. Hopefully that will be happening someday. A Rhino Records attorney faxed me a clearance in 1999 that they would not interfere with any projected CD of the "Head First" Apple Studios rough mixes (tapes they do not have in their possession), and that their discussions with a Warner Brothers attorney also led them to believe Warner Brothers also would not interfere. This was after I had a meeting with a Rhino Records attorney and presented legal documents, etc. to him and for Warner Brothers to go over which proved their lack of ownership of anything to do with this project. They pretty much acknowledged that fact, yet they were not about to hand over the Kerner/Wise mix masters or the 16-track masters in their vault to anyone. There is that axiom "ownership is 9/10th's possession." One would probably have to go to court to try and get any of those tapes handed over to them. Warner Brothers got them from Polley in 1975, just before Pete died. When Pete died, no one retrieved them.

 

8. On the first CD track, "Man Without A Heart," you can hear Pete is learning his way around the piano. How did he use the piano (composing, Badfinger live, demos) and did he have as good a talent for piano as for guitar?

Pete was a great guitar player, but not a virtuoso keyboard player. He improved as he went along and his recorded parts were usually the type that fit the arrangements really well. With Badfinger, the musical arrangement was of major importance. Bill Collins early on encouraged the keyboard aspects and when you hear "Man Without A Heart" you pretty much can tell a significant influence of the song is inspired by Pete sitting at the piano blocking out basic chords. This was one of Pete's very first songs.

 

9. The "afterword" has a lot of new information. How did you approach that?

Basically. I tried to accentuate what I considered the important developments since the publication of the last book. That would entail CD, LP releases, documentary developments, and the legal update. The court case over Joey Molland getting producer royalties and expenses for the CD Day After Day: Live was completed. I capsulized the case for readers.